Jump to content

SOTW #155: The Ladies of DC Comics [Closed!]


Apollo

Recommended Posts

Firedogx10 He nailed the theme to a T great use of color, contrast and tone


Tenderfoot; great use of render but the BG is too busy and bright tone down your brightener a little bit but overall great signature


Aphrodite: Good use of filtering, color and tone but brighten up the image a little bit overall great work,


 


Honest Mention Emrys, dnangel10


Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Apollo - Amaziiing. Feels almost official. Cool lighting and I like how you used multiple renders. Nice use of space too.
2. Aphrodite - Amazing again. Good colours, render and BG match well. Text also matches. Again, looks almost official.
3. ParasiteEve - Amazing work. Love it, has a cool feel to it that I can't put my finger on. Kind of like a pastel painting, but kind of different.

 

yes. good job kouhai. great c&c! This is so hard when I'm rushed, sorry for the shoddy feedback.

Runners ups. I'm going to blatantly steal the +/- system ParasiteEve uses, but with less detail. I'm short on time, so sorry about the rushed c&c.

*note this is a random order.

Tenderfoot
(+)cool render (+)Amazing background (+)Colours match well (+)no seriously, do you know how cool that background is? It's amazing!
(-)Render is a bit underwhelming next to background (-)Feels like a lot of open space

DNA000
(+)It's supergirl (+)good depth (+) cool text
(-)Lighting is a bit too strong

Firedogx10
(+)Render matches BG (+)Cool effects/patterns
(-)Flowers look like a layer infront of her, and not flowers enveloping her.

Emrys
(+)Nice render (+)Awesome background
(-)They look disjoint / like they're from different pictures

Tsukumo Yuma
(+)Been a while since I've been by forums, your text game is aloooot better. (+)Colours match render (+)shadow adds depth
(-)shadow is the only depth (-)Personal preference, but I'm not too keen on the render (-)render feels small/far away

 

Grats to everyone who entered. Good job!
 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Crap I almost forgot to vote.
-------------------------------
Votes
-------------------------------
 
Aphrodite:
(+) I really like the grunge look, I think it fits well with Harley's crazy personality, the lighting is really nice, Overall I think it just looks awesome. :)
 
(-) Her forehead looks slightly bleached out, but it still looks fine, other than that I think it's a pretty stop on sig.
 
(sidenote) I have such a personal hated for the bleeding cowboys font and you ended up making it work perfectly, so extra kudos for that.
 
Firedog:
(+) I love the colors and the lighting, I like how the flowers in the front are a touch out of focus, it was such a nice little detail.
(-) As much as I do like the flowers in the front, Kouhai made a really good point about them.
 
 
Apollo:
(+)Great renders, awesome background and fitting text.
(-) Ivy almost blends in too much and I'm not a big fan of the yellow everything is. (but thats just personal)
 
-------------------------------
Runner's Up
-------------------------------
 
 Tsukumo Yuma:
(+) IT'S RAVEN, text improvement, minimal but works.
(-) I see some shadow on the left hand side of the sig that should have been cleaned up (you can only see it on a white bg), while i do like that it's minimal I think a moon or clouds in the back would have given it more depth and made it even better.
 
dn_angel:
(+) Nice render, the background is nice, I think it would have been even better toned down, text is very fitting.
(-)Very bright, render looks a little messy, I can see white along the edges in some places on it.
 
Emrys:
(+) Great render, nice background and the text fits this sig.
(-) The render and background doesn't really flow well together.

tenderfoot:
(+) Nice lighting on background and render.
(-) While the lighting on both is nice, it doesn't match up very well and I think the lighting on the face of the render could be toned down a touch.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In or Sign Up