Fate/Zero encode video comparison

Hark0n · April 10, 2015

Based on discussion on deanzel's status update, a decision to make comparison between two possible encodes for dual-audio release was made.

Comparison uses BD remux in place of JP-BD (from Nyaa).

Episode 01:

____________JP-BD___________vs_________mawen1250_________vs___________UTW_____________

Screenshot gallery link: http://someimage.com/GMZx (note that the picture order in gallery is different - UTW, BD, mawen1250)

Episode 02:
It turns out there is a image limitation for posts. Comparison for episode 02 posted in separate post.

All screenshots taken with AvsPmod 2.5.1 using ffms2_FFVideoSource.

Edited April 10, 2015 by Hark0n

deanzel · April 10, 2015

Buuuuuuut... I wanted to set the record for the most comments in a Status Update (interested in actually figuring out what that is). And thanks for the comparisons. I'm trying to download the mawen version myself so we'll see how that goes...

Hark0n · April 10, 2015

Buuuuuuut... I wanted to set the record for the most comments in a Status Update (interested in actually figuring out what that is). And thanks for the comparisons. I'm trying to download the mawen version myself so we'll see how that goes...

I did add a reply in the status update, but I don't believe it is possible to make reasonable comparison there (is it even possible to post pictures?).

I am currently seeding mawen1250's release (from Nyaa), but speed is not too great.

BluerGost · April 10, 2015

Can u guys tell any difference. I certainly cant....

Edited April 10, 2015 by BluerGost

Hark0n · April 10, 2015

Can u guys tell any difference. I certainly cant....

The source (JP-BD) has noticeable aliasing which is fixed in both encodes. Check the screenshots with fire, noise difference in those is fairly visible.

I will add more screenshots when I finish downloading EP 02, I hope it will have more noticeable differences in action scenes (I will probably only include those from end of episode).

JohnFlower · April 10, 2015

Can u guys tell any difference. I certainly cant....

It's obvious... UTW has always had problems with detail loss. It's hardly a real problem though. You wont notice it while watching.

deanzel · April 10, 2015

I'll probably end up using mawen. The bigger problem will actually be getting it. It's been downloading at like 100-200 Kbps max. However, someone may be seeding on AB. I'll check out the speeds once I get back from my GMAT test

**Koby** · April 10, 2015

What about Baal's encode?

http://kametsu.com/index.php?/topic/35999-multibaal-fatezero-bd-720phi10dual-audio/

Baal · April 10, 2015

What about Baal's encode?

http://kametsu.com/index.php?/topic/35999-multibaal-fatezero-bd-720phi10dual-audio/

Since when its my encode? Video is UTW and I'm not aware of anything "better" at that resolution.

Hark0n · April 10, 2015

Episode 02:
(Remux at Nyaa was downloading too slow, so I am using different JP-BD remux for EP 02)

____________JP-BD___________vs_________mawen1250_________vs___________UTW_____________

Screenshot gallery link: http://someimage.com/BWyZ (note that the picture order in gallery is different - UTW, mawen1250, BD)

All screenshots taken with AvsPmod 2.5.1 using ffms2_FFVideoSource.

Edited April 10, 2015 by Hark0n

deanzel · April 10, 2015

Yeah... so this won't be downloaded in like forever. Only getting connected to like 1 seed/peer on the Nyaa torrent (I'm assuming that this is you Hark0n, Lativa?) and going at 150 Kb/s max. The AnimeBytes torrent (which I thought would be better) is even slower at like 10 Kb/s...

Edited April 10, 2015 by deanzel

Hark0n · April 10, 2015

Yeah... so this won't be downloaded in like forever. Only getting connected to like 1 seed/peer on the Nyaa torrent (I'm assuming that this is you Hark0n, Lativa?) and going at 150 Kb/s max. The AnimeBytes torrent is even worse at like 10 Kb/s...

I could free up some place in seedbox and try to seed from there, but it will still take some time to do.

Alternatively I could use other means to send the file to You (MEGA, FTP).

deanzel · April 10, 2015

Yeah... so this won't be downloaded in like forever. Only getting connected to like 1 seed/peer on the Nyaa torrent (I'm assuming that this is you Hark0n, Lativa?) and going at 150 Kb/s max. The AnimeBytes torrent is even worse at like 10 Kb/s...
I could free up some place in seedbox and try to seed from there, but it will still take some time to do.
Alternatively I could use other means to send the file to You (MEGA, FTP).

Yeah, that would definitely be better if it isn't too inconvenient for you. That or direct/private seeding (something like that). I'll see if it picks up at all but it was pretty bad last night (was today) and of course my client crashed when I was having it run on my older computer. Now, it's running on my newer main laptop.

EDIT: I should be able to grab the first two episodes. I'm at like 50% for both of them but speeds are getting worse

Edited April 10, 2015 by deanzel

Hark0n · April 10, 2015

OK! First will try with seedbox, if that fails, that I will look into other alternatives.

Currently uploading. Improved torrent seeding can be expected in about 12 hours from now (probably).

deanzel · April 10, 2015

OK! First will try with seedbox, if that fails, that I will look into other alternatives.
Currently uploading. Improved torrent seeding can be expected in about 12 hours from now (probably).

I'll still be here as it is down to 40KB/s. Thanks!

Edited April 10, 2015 by deanzel

JohnFlower · April 10, 2015

I can have this up in ~3 hours. Torrent only.

deanzel · April 10, 2015

I can have this up in ~3 hours. Torrent only.

That would be awesome Flower-sama. Would it be a private torrent as not having the rando leechers helps? Edited April 10, 2015 by deanzel

JohnFlower · April 10, 2015

No, I'll just reseed the nyaa one for a while.

deanzel · April 10, 2015

Ok cool. That helps just as much.

If you guys are using a client like Vuze which can block/limit certain leechers, I am the one in 'MURRICA with Cox (68.99.something I believe). I am not one of the 10 leechers from China who are not sharing...

EDIT: God damn the Chinese fuckers getting 1+ MB/s down while I'm getting 70-80KB/s

EDIT 2: Thank you based French seeder (JF or H0) seeding me at about 2MB/s.

Edited April 11, 2015 by deanzel

deanzel · April 11, 2015

Got it bros. Thanks a ton!

Sign In

Fate/Zero encode video comparison

Recommended Posts

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Link to comment

Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0 members

Similar Content