Jump to content

Thoughts?


Irish

Recommended Posts

Hmmm.... CnC? Sure~

The render and the bg don't seem to go together very well and the brush stroke on the right doesnt seem to fit, but other than that it looks pretty good~ Maybe add some more green onto it?~

Its not a render, Its a stock....

V1

shigeno.png

V2

goro22.png

V3

this is before i add brush strokes or anything...

goro21.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like this

goro21.png

It looks good with the color emphasized. Also nice you removed the white stroke

To be honest that one has no flow what so ever. The render/stock just seems pasted onto an non-matching background. Leki I am shocked you would consider that the best being a graphic designer yourself.

Remember flow, lighting, contrast, and blending all play apart. It's not a matter of personal preference but rather which does all of that the best that really shows someones graphical talent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well I did state it was to my personal preference.

If I have to say it as a professional I would say V2

But the one I stated about is my own choice.

^_-

I didn't mean it quite like I made it sound (after I read what I said just now).

What I mean is that when people show off their work or ask for C&C, we as fellow graphic designers should try to help them on those aspects as C&C to help them improve. We can still have favorites of course based on our own likes, but we should try to also give advice on what to do to improve if possible and which flows better, etc..

I know I didn't do it myself though and I can't ask others to do what I myself didn't. I was planning on offering advice but at the time of my original post I didn't have much time to do so.

Honestly a render like that is kind of hard to work with. I myself find that green or red really doesn't often flow correctly unless used on like colored designs. Hence why I felt v2 flowed a little better. The coloring helped it to feel like it belonged there rather than just pasted on top like the others.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I didn't mean it quite like I made it sound (after I read what I said just now).

What I mean is that when people show off their work or ask for C&C, we as fellow graphic designers should try to help them on those aspects as C&C to help them improve. We can still have favorites of course based on our own likes, but we should try to also give advice on what to do to improve if possible and which flows better, etc..

I know I didn't do it myself though and I can't ask others to do what I myself didn't. I was planning on offering advice but at the time of my original post I didn't have much time to do so.

Honestly a render like that is kind of hard to work with. I myself find that green or red really doesn't often flow correctly unless used on like colored designs. Hence why I felt v2 flowed a little better. The coloring helped it to feel like it belonged there rather than just pasted on top like the others.

this is the Original stock i had to work with.... Im still adjusting to stocks instead of renders... I used to only do renders, but I felt like a change in pace...

40033.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In