SOTW #172: Shueisha [Closed!]

[† ParasiteEve]

-------------------------------

Votes

-------------------------------

 

Kouhai:

(+) Sharp and the blurred background look really good together
 

(-) I stared at it for like 5 mins and couldn't really find anything I didn't like... 

 

PS: GIVE ME YOUR SECRETS TO MAKING OVERLAPPING TEXT LOOK GOOD!!!!!!

 

poetictagedy:

(+) Nice use of a manga render, faint gray border and the text looks great. 

(-) Right above the text looks a little washed out and blurry.

 

Athena:

(+) Improved text, cute colors and render.

(-) The dark purple in a couple of spots is distracting, also you should start saving your sigs in PNG format, it can give them a cleaner look and JPGS tend to blur when you save them.
 

-------------------------------

Runner Up

-------------------------------

 

 Tsukumo Yuma:

(+) Cute render.
(-) Not much going on.

 

[Kouhai]

Weee, I'm stealing Eve's voting style.

Haha, it's too good to ignore!

I just got home and I'm dead tired so I'm going to skip cnc. (forgive me, I might add it when I wake up).

Changed my mind, I'll do it now but it'll be brief. :s

1. Athena

 (+) contains nice shoujo feel. (+) cool blending FG/BG.

   (-) Personal preference, I felt your border was too strong.

2. Eve

 (+) awesome lighting/blending (+) great job using a live-action render. (It's REALLY hard using those!)

   (-) I would have liked to see more of the render than the face. :x

Haha, text is toooo hard. I've resorted to making a seperate .psd for text now and just duplicating it in.

3. Poe

 (+) great choreography. (+)cool text.

   (-) FG/BG look a bit separate.

4. Tsukumo Yuma

 (+) cool gif. (+) gif goes with bg.

  (-) Render and BG feel bit off together.

 

1. Kouhai - Just one problem, the left side of your sig looks perfect however to your right that brush work looks very out of place.

Haha, omo. I hate them too but they were stuck in there from image->apply image, and I was too lazy to go back. T_T

[† LimitLess]

Haha, omo. I hate them too but they were stuck in there from image->apply image, and I was too lazy to go back. T_T

 

Well you're better than me, I didn't even enter this week XD

[† ParasiteEve]

 

2. Eve

 (+) awesome lighting/blending (+) great job using a live-action render. (It's REALLY hard using those!)

   (-) I would have liked to see more of the render than the face. :x

Haha, text is toooo hard. I've resorted to making a seperate .psd for text now and just duplicating it in.

 

Yeah, I knew the photo I picked was gonna be an issue being that it was a close up on her face. (actually is was an issue, OF A MAGAZINE! everyone is allowed to shoot me for that one) 

I really wish I would have done what Poe suggested and move the text and crop the sig. (Note to self: Channel Poe for sig help next time) 

 

[Alice]

Voting is closed.  Sorry delayed.