Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
poetictragedy

SOTW #102: Letters "A" through "I" [Results]

Recommended Posts

wonTi.jpg

Signature of the Week #102

Theme: Anime/Manga/Game starting with the letters "A" through "I"!


Rules:
  • All entries are to be submitted by Friday, February 1.
  • Your entry must be related to the chosen theme.
  • Only one entry per participant. However, you may edit your entry until the deadline.
  • Signatures must be your own work.
  • Entries can be in GIF, JPG, JPEG or PNG format, and should be no larger than 600x220 pixels. Animated signatures are allowed.
  • Pre-made signatures are allowed, as long as they have not been used in a past Kametsu competition.
  • In addition to your entry, please also submit a theme idea for next week's competition. Please check this thread to make sure your theme has not already been used.
  • Please read all Graphical Division Rules and Forum Rules before entering. All rules apply.
  • This thread is strictly for entry submission, voting, and results. Other SOTW discussions belong in a separate SOTW Discussions thread. ANY DISCUSSIONS POSTED HERE WILL BE DELETED.
Edited by poetictragedy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[VOTING]

Rules:
  • All votes are to be submitted by Sunday, February 3.
  • To vote, reply to this thread, listing your top three signatures IN ORDER. First place gets three points, second gets two points, third gets one point; the person with the most points wins.
  • Along with your vote, you may say why you picked the signatures you picked, and/or leave constructive criticism for any entry you wish. Do not feel that you have to, but you may if you want.
  • Keep in mind the theme and the connection between the theme and the signature. Please do not vote for the render/image, but for the OVERALL signature you think looks best.
  • Avoid favoritism.
  • You may not vote for yourself.
  • This thread is strictly for entry submission, voting, and results. Other SOTW discussions belong in a separate SOTW Discussions thread. ANY DISCUSSIONS POSTED HERE WILL BE DELETED.
Example:

Sally - Fit the theme the best.
Bob - Text could have been better.
Anna - Render placement was a little off.


Entries:
Dreamcastor:
BelldandySIG_zps5998a635.jpg

Breathless:
cgsig.png

ogromm:
edwardelric.jpg

poetictragedy:
vXtUFCo.jpg

Edited by poetictragedy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[RESULTS]
First Place
poetictragedy

Second Place
Dreamcastor

Third Place
Breathless
ogromm


Point Breakdown:
poetictragedy - 21
Dreamcastor - 14
ogromm - 12
Breathless - 12 Edited by poetictragedy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm watching Ah! My Goddess right now, which is why I was inspired to do a Belldandy SIG. :)


 


BelldandySIG_zps5998a635.jpg


 


Theme:  Vanilla & Chocola


Edited by Dreamcastor

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mine is Initial D, as you can see below me :P
 
ChaverSignature.jpg

MOD NOTE: J-Lord has brought it to our attention that this is a signature he made. According to the rules, "signatures must be your own work", so unfortunately, this is not a valid entry. So sorry! ~poetictragedy

Edited by poetictragedy
If people have signatures disabled, they wouldn't see your entry!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh my goodness, I worked on this for like over four hours. Granted, I did scrap the whole thing at one point, but oh man.

It's Isaac from Golden Sun.

vXtUFCo.jpg

Theme: Animals

Edited by poetictragedy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dreamcastor - Good colors and text, though it seems a little plain.

Breathless - I like the composition, but I think you blurred too much on the girl's hair.

ogromm - Good text.

Edited by poetictragedy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Poe - Nice, I loved Golden Sun! Anyway - really cool work. The text is a bit tricky to read over the scarf. It's really awesome though!
Ogomn - Again, cool job! I find it a bit hard to keep my focus on the render. 
Dreamcaster - Great sig, alot of subtle things going on here. I think maybe too subtle, it's lacking some impact.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Poe -- Ye, Golden Sun. It flows well, and the lighting and background match the style of the render. The left side might be a little too empty, but I have no idea.


ogromm -- The text pulls attention away from the render, but otherwise I like it. Ed stands out well while still appearing to be a part of the scene.


Dreamcastor -- The border and text are very faint! This lack of contrast can make the right side of the signature look empty. Otherwise, I like the colours and render placement. It's very feminine and soothing.


Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dreamcaster:  Simple energetic,but a bit bright for my tastes.
Poetic Tragedy: Love the action pose, again way bright for my tastes, but I am a bit odd for that.  A bit of odd shadow at the back end of the signature not sure if that was by design or not.
Ogromm:  The left hand looks real lazy, but overall not a bad signature.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.


  • Similar Content

    • By poetictragedy
      WINNER'S CIRCLE
      Click on the winner's name to see their entry.
       

      COMPETITIONS #1-100
      WINNERS


    • By Alice
      BANNER OF THE MONTH: JANUARY
       
      RULES:
      All entries are to be submitted by January 23rd.
      Voting will take place between January 24th & 31st.
      The theme this month: NONE
      Only one entry per participant. However, you may edit your entry until the deadline.
      Banners must be your own work.
      Entries are to be GIF or PNG format, and should be 1600 (or more) x160 pixels
      Text must say KAMETSU not KAMETSU FORUMS!
      Animated banners are allowed.
      Pre-made banners are allowed, as long as they have not been used in a past Kametsu competition.
      Please read all Graphical Division Rules and Forum Rules before entering. All rules apply.
×
×
  • Create New...