Jump to content

Write

Crusader
  • Posts

    21
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by Write

  1. 1.) Apollo: Overall a good entry. A little over saturated but otherwise nice.


     


    2.) Dreamcastor Rei: I feel the border is unnecessary.


     


    3.) Jabonline20: The renders look ill-fitting for that type of bg. I also feel having the character featured twice is unnecessary.


     


    >Radical Ed: I don't feel like the composition is original. To be frank it just looks like a poverty version of the sig I submitted the other week. Nothing stands out except the render and even that is drowned out by excessive filers that don't compliment the colors of the character.


    • Like 1
  2. With the exception of Dreamcaster Rei, every sig is relying on rain effects. There either are no other effects used or they're used poorly. I'm not sure why anyone would be influenced to believed the gif animation would make their sig look better in the first place.


     


    Kora - The animation is more than rain falling, which objectively puts your entry above the others.


     


    Dreamcaster Rei - A solid entry all around. The text bothers me, I think it's unnecessary and takes away from the overall composition.


     


    Apollo - Your entry would look good without the rain animation, which is good either way. The render is actually in line with the theme instead of being shoehorned in after the fact.


     


    I think everyone would have been better off had you worried about standing out rather than going with the crowd. What made voting difficult (for me) was the fact I almost had to disregard the rain altogether since mostly every entry used it [abused] the same way.


    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In