Hughes of course, that neck slice should have bought him enough time to at least escape! Gretel (Black Lagoon) - She had so much potential for an entire story arc, what better addition to the crew than a homicidal kid that can snipe?!? Plus, I think revy would have really changed with her around, either more agressive -or more motherly, forming the complete dysfunctional family on board. Wrath (FMA,shamballa) He had turned good, he had gotten automail, he had so much more potential to fight alongside al. He probably could have forged through the gate himself, meaning a probably more epic fight to get ed back. Wins best sacrifice award hands down, anchored to the ground while being eaten, just to know that your actions are both saving a person you care about and redeeming yourself with them, and also the fact that your common enemy is about to get dismantled at the atomic level.